A simple, monolithic form of the medieval castle brings to mind the modernist realizations of villas by Frank Lloyd Wright and the postmodern buildings of Mario Botta.
Located in the north of England, the fortified castle, which architectural structure was expanded over the years under the influence of the military development. The early parts of the castle were built ab. 1096.
Downtown Castle in the neo-Gothic style, subordinated to the ideas of romance and picturesqueness, is the building purposely fragmented with a complex formal and functional structure, stylized along the line of the medieval pattern.
The devoid of the ornamentation interior of the Medieval English castle has its rich stately form due to the deployed architectural constructions (arch, vault).
The interior of the neo-Gothic castle is modeled on the decorative style of the Gothic cathedrals. The ornament is an artificial growths that do not interact with the structural elements.
1. The False Image
The term "The Middle Ages" is difficult to define. According to Umberto Eco, this concept was invented in order to name the millennium, which no one could define as it was located between two "excellent" epochs: the one was already felt pride of, and the other was much yearned for.[1] The researcher raises the question: How can one stick a label on many centuries so differing one from other? On the one hand, there are times since the fall of the Roman Empire to the restoration of Carolings, when Europe was experiencing the most serious in its entire history crisis: political, demographic, religious and linguistic (this list could be very long). On the other hand, the Middle Ages are also the century of renewal after the 1st millennium, in respect of which it is said about the first industrial revolution, the time of the creation of the modern languages and nations, the birth of democracy, bank, check and accounting, the period of the revolutionary changes in maritime and land transport, in techniques of farming and craft production, when it is invented compass, arched ceiling, and at the end the gunpowder and printing. How can one combine the centuries, in which the Arabs translate Aristotle and practice medicine and astronomy, while in the eastern part of Spain, despite leaving the "barbaric" era behind, Europe still cannot boast about its own culture?[2]
Meanwhile, in terms of the design features The Middle Ages are surprisingly consistent. Despite the numerous variations and modifications of the leading themes, this era’ design is easy to grasp into the framework of classification. Furthermore, the architecture and design characteristic for The Middle Ages cannot be confused with any other stylistics. The structural homogeneity of the era, numbering ten centuries, gives the impression as if time floated then in another, slower rhythm.
At the same time, one has to pay attention to the fact that the image of the Middle Ages, which can be built on the basis of examples of the medieval architecture, preserved to our days, often loses its original character and significance. Firstly, the medieval buildings have often been constructed over many years. Planned with a grand scale the assumptions have changed under construction, constantly staying in tune with the current times. This can be seen particularly in the example of the cathedrals, construction of which was started back in line with the Romanesque style, characteristic for The early Middle Ages, and the final shape and character have been given already under the influence of the Gothic tendencies (ex, Durham Cathedral, County Durham, England 1110-1133). Moreover, as a result of numerous wars the medieval buildings were often destroyed, and their reconstruction have already been conducted in accordance with the new rules. With the development of the military technologies and techniques of attacking the medieval buildings were constantly being improved in terms of defense, adapted to the new war standards. Castle walls began to be strengthened with defensive towers, gates were fortified and also there were introduced the additional rings of walls. The crew of the castle has become more numerous and so the living space was expanded.[3] The war was both a target and means in the "medieval game" carried on constantly. The highest stake was the great wealth afterwards reinvested into the strategic warfare. The layering of building serving for the defensive purposes within the medieval castles is the real record of the trend. In this sense, it is impossible to deny the dynamics of the medieval architecture, reflecting social and cultural changes of that time.
The image of the medieval architecture, despite ten centuries of development, has been shortened by the history of art due to neo-Gothic. This style, characteristic for the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, took over design trends of The late Middle Ages as a kind of eclectic plaything, using them in isolation from the original functions. Neo-Gothic offered the romantic, detached from reality vision of the Middle Ages, as exemplified by the neo-Gothic buildings such as: Downtown Castle (completed around 1778 years), Cardiff Castle, Castell Coch (1871-1891, Wales).
Looking at The Middle Ages through the prism of neo-Gothic buildings - both public and private – we completely move away from the truth concerning the ten centuries of the medieval architecture, in which the fundamental role was played by the functionality as opposed to the neo-gothic picturesqueness.
[1] U. Eco, The Art and Beauty of the Middle Ages, ed. The Sign, Krakow 1994
[2] Op. cit U. Eco.
[3] J. Pile, The design history, ed. Arcady, Warsaw, 2004
Marika Ika Wato
2. The Roots of the Modern Residential Architecture: The Middle Ages
Bibliographic description to this article:
The Roots of the Modern Residential Architecture: The Middle Ages / M.I. Wato. CyberEmpathy: Visual Communication and New Media in Art, Science, Humanities, Design and Technology. ISSUE 7/2013. ISSN 2299-906X. Kokazone.
Mode of access: Internet via World Wide Web.
Abstract:
The Middle Ages are surprisingly consistent. Despite the numerous variations and modifications of the leading themes, this era’ design is easy to grasp into the framework of classification. Furthermore, the architecture and design characteristic for The Middle Ages cannot be confused with any other stylistics. The structural homogeneity of the era, numbering ten centuries, gives the impression as if time floated then in another, slower rhythm.
The Roots of the Modern Residential Architecture: The Middle Ages
Marika Ika Wato
CyberEmpathy ISSUE 7 / 2013: Visual Strategies
2. The roots of the present
A simple, monolithic form of the preserved to this day original medieval castles in the vicinity of East England brings to mind the modernist realizations of villas by Frank Lloyd Wright and the postmodern buildings of Mario Botta, program’ objective of which was functional design focused on the human needs. East of England with its regular, fairly flat landscape, remote from the border with Wales has remained relatively peaceful region in The Middle Ages. Castles located in this area have been preserved in their original, not fragmented, "monomodular" form. There they did not grow to such proportions and at such rate as the castles located in the more troubled areas of the country, such as North of England, where the buildup of the following functional modules served the purposes of defense and harmonized with the burgeoning social structure within the castle walls.
Castles built in the neo-Gothic style became the negation of the idea behind the construction of medieval castles, both in their primary, monolithic form and secondary, complicated, stratified, fragmented one. The neo-Gothic Castles have complex construction plan, and a complex formal and functional structure (adapted to the new needs of the XVIII and XIX centuries). Usually there were richly decorated buildings similar to the Gothic cathedrals, and then supplemented by the elements completely alien to the medieval stylistics of the private - residential space.
The root of the described difference between The Middle Ages and neo-Gothic has an ideological nature, while the imitation has a purely formal, stylistic character. The fact is that the eclectic manner of neo-Gothic distorts the true image of the medieval architecture – that original one, main goal of which was to adapt to the current needs of human.
A rational approach to the construction, which characterized the Middle Ages, makes possible to trace in it the roots of the contemporary architecture, equally functional and passive, in equal measure focused on the use of the natural materials. The beginning of these architectural trends can be observed in the era of modernism, which was born in the spirit of opposition to the eclectic, exaggerated solutions of the XIX century. These trends persist to this day, enhanced by the emergence of new technologies in the construction industry.
3 The residential towers
The first medieval English castles were wooden buildings, erected by Normans. In time, they began to use stone, but floors, ceilings and roofs were still made of wood. The medieval castles were used for defense, and therefore they were built on the natural elevations, so that towered over the whole area. The buildings were surrounded by the stone walls (originally they were wooden palisades). Many medieval castles have the form of residential tower with the vertical functional structure. The utility rooms were at the bottom, and the residential ones at the top. These are the compact structures with unified, closed surfaces of the walls with the small window holes. In the medieval times windows were not equipped with glass, so their small size protected the interior from the effects of bad weather conditions.
The modern residential towers (vertical houses) can be found in different parts of the world. Their resemblance to the medieval castles regarding operating the form of architecture is surprising. This indicates not so much attempts of formal or stylistic imitation, but rather the fact that modernist principle of "form resulting from the function" is timeless and universal.
Below there is a juxtaposition of examples of the medieval buildings in relation to the modern buildings operating the similar formal principles: